Comment and analysis on all things CharlotteRSS

CATS cost overrun of the moment

Per the UPoR:

Problems with a contractor will force the Charlotte Area Transit System to spend an additional $950,000 to upgrade capacity on the light-rail line.

In April 2014, the City Council awarded a $16.5 million contract with Balfour Beatty Infrastructure, mostly to expand four Lynx Blue Line stations so they can handle three-car trains instead of the standard two-car trains.

The construction was supposed to be finished in September. But the city said the project was delayed due to “changes in contract management, additional work added to the project and insufficient contractor resources.”

The city hopes the work will be finished by the end of June.

Am I surprised by this? No. If there’s one thing that rail transit system know how to do, it’s have construction projects run over budget.

No Comments

Top unserved air markets from CLT

On this travel day for many, here’s a list of the largest unserved domestic air markets within a 1,050 mile radius from Charlotte Douglas International Airport. Ranks are based upon the average amount that people spent traveling between those cities and Charlotte (average number of passengers a day times the average one-way fare) during the first quarter of 2015:

  1. Madison, WI $9,689
  2. Wichita, KS, $6,125
  3. Green Bay, WI $5,718
  4. Sioux Falls, SD $5,320
  5. Shreveport, LA $4,921
  6.  Flint, MI $4,910
  7. Cedar Rapids, IA $4,886
  8. Moline, IL $4,354
  9. Stevens Point, WI $4,179
Comments Off on Top unserved air markets from CLT

Charlotte housing market doing below average

The UPoR runs a Bloomberg story that kind of misses the point on the Charlotte housing market. The headline is “Home prices rise 4.3 percent in Charlotte over the year.” That sounds really impressive until you read the actual article:

The 5.5 percent increase in the S&P/Case-Shiller index of property values was the biggest year-over-year gain since August 2014 and followed a 5.1 percent advance in the previous month, the group said in a report Tuesday.

The median estimate of economists surveyed by Bloomberg called for a 5.2 percent increase. Nationally, prices rose 4.9 percent. In Charlotte, prices rose 4.3 percent.

If you look at the actual press release, you’ll see that Charlotte ranks 16th in home price appreciation of the 20 cities covered by the Case-Shiller study. Be nice if the UPoR did a follow-up story examining why the Charlotte housing market has lagged behind San Francisco, Denver, Portland, Dallas, Seattle, Miami, San Diego, Los Angeles, Tampa, Atlanta, Las Vegas, Detroit (!), Phoenix, and Boston over the past year.

Comments Off on Charlotte housing market doing below average

Appeals Court OKs Transfer of Asheville Water System

My latest article for Carolina Journal. And yes, this decision could also have an impact on future legislation over the control of Charlotte Douglas International Airport:

RALEIGH — The city of Asheville and customers living outside the city who rely on Asheville for their drinking water long have had a contentious relationship. The issue was again before the state’s second highest court in October, this time over whether a law passed in 2013 taking control of the water system away from Asheville could pass muster under the state’s constitution.

Though Asheville currently operates a water system, it does not provide sewer services. That instead is the responsibility of the Metropolitan Sewerage District of Buncombe County. In 2013, the General Assembly passed a local bill shifting control of the water authority from the city to MSD.

The city sued to block the transfer, and in June 2014, Superior Court Judge Howard Manning held that the statute violated three provisions of the state constitution:

• It is a “local law” relating to “health,” “sanitation,” and “non-navigable streams,” in violation of Article II, Section 24.

• It constitutes an unlawful taking of Asheville’s property without just compensation in violation of Article I, Sections 19 and 35.

• It violates Asheville’s rights under the “law of the land” clause found in Article I, Section 19.

The state appealed Manning’s ruling, which a three-judge panel of the N.C. Court of Appeals overturned.

“We disagree and hold that the Transfer Provision does not violate these constitutional provisions,” wrote Judge Chris Dillon for a unanimous appeals court.

Under North Carolina law, localities are creations of the state, and the General Assembly retains the authority to regulate towns and counties except to the degree that it conflicts with the state or federal constitutions.

Since 1917, the N.C. Constitution has prohibited the General Assembly from enacting so-called “local” laws that touch on any of 14 subjects, including laws “relating to health [or] sanitation” and laws “relating to non-navigable streams.” Asheville contended that the transfer, because it was in a local bill and related to both those topics, was invalid.

The Court of Appeals came to a different conclusion. “[I]n the present case, we need not reach whether the Transfer Provision constitutes a ‘local law,” wrote Dillon.

“Rather, we hold that it is not plain and clear and beyond reasonable doubt that the Transfer Provision falls within the ambit of either prohibited subject identified by the trial court.” (Emphasis in decision.)

Dillon noted that litigation over Asheville’s water system had established that “the mere implication of water or a water system in a legislative enactment does not necessitate a conclusion that it relates to health and sanitation in violation of the Constitution.”

Examining the new law’s stated purpose and text, the appeals court found that the law appeared to prioritize concerns about governance and the quality of services rendered over health and sanitation issues. Nor did the law “fall within the ambit of the phrase ‘relating to non-navigable streams.’”

The city also claimed that the transfer violated the “law of the land” clause of the N.C. Constitution, in that there was no “rational basis” to treat Asheville differently from other municipalities that operate water systems and that there was no “rational basis” to transfer the water system from the city to the MSD.

The appeals court disagreed.

“Asheville contends, and the trial court agreed, that the General Assembly had no ‘rational’ basis for singling out Asheville in the Transfer Provision,” wrote Dillon.

“Assuming that the Transfer Provision has this effect, we believe that the fact that the General Assembly irrationally singles out one municipality in legislation merely means that the legislation is a ‘local’ law; it does not render the legislation unconstitutional, per se.”

The city also claimed that it was entitled to compensation from the state for the value of the water system. The Court of Appeals again disagreed, noting that in the 1923 case Trenton v. New Jersey, the U.S. Supreme Court held that compensation in such circumstances was not necessary. The appeals court also noted that cases from the Minnesota and Pennsylvania supreme courts had reached the same conclusion.

The case is City of Asheville v State of North Carolina, (14-1255).

Comments Off on Appeals Court OKs Transfer of Asheville Water System

Your ACC bowl update

Care of Joe Giglio of the Raleigh News & Observer, is available here. Let’s say thinks are still not well sorted:

N.C. State could play in the Belk Bowl in Charlotte … or the Pinstripe Bowl in New York … or the Gator Bowl in Jacksonville, Fla. … or the Military Bowl in Annapolis, Md. … or the Independence Bowl in Shreveport, La.

Seems that Virginia Tech, with longtime coach Frank Beamer in his last game, is at the top of the Belk Bowl’s want list. The caveats: Virginia Tech has to become bowl eligible by beating Virginia this weekend and some other things have to happen.

Comments Off on Your ACC bowl update

The Panthers get flexed

The Panthers game at New Orleans a week from Sunday, December 6th has been moved from a 1:00pm start time to a 4:25pm start. Plan your TV viewing accordingly.

Bonus thought: Be interesting to see if game time for any of the other remaining Panthers games get moved. Carolina plays Atlanta on December 13 (home) and 27 (away) and is at the New York Giants on December 20th, all of which are — for now — 1:00pm starts.

Comments Off on The Panthers get flexed

How comic book stores stay relevant

As the Winston-Salem Journal explains, they commission exclusive covers of popular comics.

Comments Off on How comic book stores stay relevant

Why do people in old movies talk weird?

Great question, and How Stuff Works provides the answer:

Comments Off on Why do people in old movies talk weird?

Criminal no-go areas gets voted down in committee

Has there ever been an idea in Charlotte that got this much attention that ended up with so little support?

Comments Off on Criminal no-go areas gets voted down in committee

Clip and save research item of the moment

Study: Year-round school calendars could hurt home prices — based on data from Wake County.

Comments Off on Clip and save research item of the moment
December 2015
« Nov    

RSS Feeds


  • 1. Charlotte bloggers

  • 2. Other NC Bloggers

  • 3. National blogs

  • 4. Media Blogs

  • JLF Network Websites & Blogs